Ask Hilda

Prescription Problem
Hilda
I just paid $150 for anti-biotics, but my plan says $30 brand name drug co-pay. What's going on?
--Jay in NY
Read answer


Maternity Mystery

Hilda
I'm having trouble finding a plan that will cover me if I'm pregnant. Is there one out there?
--"Preggo" in GA
Read answer
Got a Question For Hilda?

She's Got Answers
Hilda knows best, so ask her anything. But be warned, she tells it like it is.
Ask Question
Newsletter

Hilda's Guide to Choosing a Health Plan


First you gotta understand the basic terms. Beyond that, it's really not rocket science. Everything you need to know about health insurance can be found in the wisdom of game shows.


The Price is Right - Choosing a Plan by the Numbers
Choosing a plan by the numbers is like the Price is Right Showcase Showdown. Here's how to pick a price without going over your limit.

To start, ask yourself two things:
1. What is my risk tolerance?
2. How much money could I access if the worst happened?

When it comes to the "accessing money" part, don't get all panicky. I know times are tight. I can't even run to the Waffle House without using my credit card. But that doesn't mean that if the worst happened, I couldn't pay a hospital a couple thousand to cover a big bill. (I could use that Waffle House credit card if I had to). Or, I could ask the hospital to put me on a payment plan. Most will do it, and some will even stretch the plan over a year or more depending on circumstances. What is important to note is that this only matters if the worst happens.

That's where your risk-tolerance comes in. The higher you set your deductible, the lower your premium will be. But just like the Showcase Showdown, the question is how high is too high. You should know that most people don't use the bulk of their deductible. Only 16% of people with $2,000 deductibles use that entire amount in one year. I know this because the fancy insurance company told me. So you have to balance the risk of the worst happening against the benefit of having a lower monthly premium.

Where do you find the balance? Personally I find the balance in a rosé spritzer and a Game Show Network fix, but that's neither here nor there. With the risk vs. exposure equation, you find the balance in the numbers. You can boil every plan down to the maximum annual financial exposure. The plan deductible plus the out of pocket maximum is the most you will pay in one year. A $1,000 deductible with an out-of pocket maximum of $2,000 ... equals a maximum exposure of $3,000.

$1,000(deductible) + $2,000(out of pocket max) = maximum cabbage you will spend in one year.

If that number doesn't keep you up at night, go higher. The higher you get this number, the lower your monthly premium will be. And for me, a lower monthly premium helps me sleep like a baby. Well, that and the aforementioned rosé spritzer. But remember Bob Barker's advice and don't bet too high. If you go over your risk tolerance all you get is a "thanks for playing" and a reminder to have your pet spayed or neutered.

The bottom line, in this case, is the bottom line. Balance what you can afford today with the bill you might receive tomorrow -- if the worst happened.

Read less...

The Dating Game - Matching Your Needs
Trying to find the right health insurance plan is likegoing on blind dates. You can ask questions up front, but you may not know what you've got until you spend time together. Ask the right pre-date questions to avoid surprises.

Read more...

(Don't) Press Your Luck - Watch Out for Hidden Whammies
Ever wonder why some insurance plans are a fraction of the cost of others? These, too good to be true, plans are full of hidden Whammies.

Read more...